Bets

Will Brandon Aiyuk Ever Play in the NFL Again?

The mercurial wide receiver will likely be released by the 49ers in the coming days. Is any other team willing to take a chance on him?’

Brandon Aiyuk walks off the field following the San Francisco 49ers-Seattle Seahawks game in 2024.
Photo by Cooper Neill/Getty Images

Key Takeaways

  • Brandon Aiyuk’s uncertain NFL future hinges on an expected 49ers release after a prolonged split with the team and no game action since his October 2024 ACL and MCL tears.
  • Mike Florio and Devin McCourty urge San Francisco to move on, arguing that keeping Aiyuk in unpaid roster-exemption limbo serves no strategic purpose.
  • The Commanders, Raiders and Rams lead the potential landing spots, but ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler says Aiyuk’s market may amount to a minimum-salary deal, tryout or practice-squad opportunity.

The Brandon Aiyuk saga is the NFL’s never-ending story.

New, brief chapters are written every few months, but a conclusion always seems far off.

Aiyuk has not played in an NFL game since October 20, 2024 against the Kansas City Chiefs, when he suffered a devastating torn ACL and MCL.

Since then, Aiyuk has been at odds with the 49ers’ front office, and has been openly flirting with other NFL teams (namely the Washington Commanders).

The 49ers placed Aiyuk on the reserve/left squad list last December.

Aiyuk applied for reinstatement in late October of this year and was granted it on November 9. The 49ers must now make a decision on what to do with Aiyuk before November 23.

The Niners could release Aiyuk, or they could keep him and put him on the 53-man roster. All indications are that the 49ers are done with the wide receiver, who had back-to-back 1,000-yard receiving seasons for the franchise in 2022-23 and 2023-24.

“It means absolutely nothing to our team,” 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan said in regard to Aiyuk being reinstated. “I think we got a two-week roster exemption and that’s all administrative stuff to me.”

Stubborn San Francisco
Considering that the 49ers have not yet released Aiyuk, which has long been the probable outcome, many believe that the franchise is punishing the wide receiver for his erratic behavior over the past two years.

NFL insider Mike Florio and former Patriots star Devin McCourty talked about the Aiyuk-49ers situation last week.

Florio: The 49ers are going to cut him at some point, and the way the CBA works … this is something I was told about, I tracked down the provisions. Because he has a roster exemption with the 49ers right now, and because he wasn’t on the team earlier this year. He didn’t show up. There’s some specific language in there and he falls within the scope of it. While he’s on this roster exemption, they don’t have to pay him. Based upon him being on the books for $13.75 million in salary this year, which—I don’t know why—but I know that that’s the number. They would have owed him $1.5 million [after the trade deadline], but because of this roster exemption they don’t have to pay him. They have until the 24th of November. At that point they’re going to have to pay him. So they’re going to cut him by then. So, why not just cut the guy?

Why force him to hang around for two weeks when you know you’re going to cut him anyway? You’re not gaining anything and it just looks petty and small for them to delay this any longer than it has to be delayed.

McCourty: So he’s allowed back in the building and everything. The whole situation is unfortunate. It didn’t work in the beginning, and now this is just the end, and no one wants to move on and just be done with it.

Florio: They have an agreement, I’m told, where he is working out on his own. So he’s excused from all team activities. He’s stuck in this limbo now, and there’s nothing he can do about it under the CBA. But if you’re the 49ers, what are you trying to prove? Are you mad at him, or are you mad at yourselves because you could have traded him and you didn’t. Like, who are you really mad at?

And I’ll say one last thing to the people out there who will point out, ‘Well he was a jerk and he gets what he deserves. Again, if you’re one of the ones who were diagnosing him with having a mental health condition based upon his social media activities over the summer, show him some grace. The things that caused him to make you conclude that he’s a jerk are manifestations of this mental health problem that you seem to think he has. Either way, the 49ers I think are in the wrong here. They dragged this thing out. He applied for reinstatement on October 27th. The league dragged it out, and now the 49ers are dragging it out. You gained nothing by this strategically. Cut the guy today.

McCourty: I agree 100 percent. This situation is unfortunate. Whatever has happened has happened.

Like, the San Francisco 49ers are in a great position to do everything they want to do this year. Move on from Aiyuk. Allow him to have an opportunity to get back in this league. I wish the best for him because I’m one of those people who thought something was going on, so hopefully he’s doing better now, and will have the ability to help some football team, especially if that’s what’s best for him mentally right now.

Florio: It’s just bad karma for the 49ers. When things are going well you don’t want bad karma. You want good karma. Get some good karma, 49ers. Release Brandon Aiyuk and let him get on with his life.

Teams that could be interested in signing Brandon Aiyuk
Aiyuk could be waived by the 49ers at any moment. Teams around the NFL clearly weren’t interested in giving up draft capital to obtain Aiyuk, as the trade deadline came and went without a move. We will soon find out if any team is interested in bringing him in at all.

“The market is, at very best, a minimum salary somewhere. A tryout, or a practice squad spot,” ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler said on The Rich Eisen Show.

There are plenty of teams in the playoff hunt that are currently in need of wide receiver help. The Giants, Steelers, Packers, Seahawks, and Patriots have been mentioned as solid landing spots for the 28-year-old.

Three other teams have come up more consistently when it comes to Aiyuk chatter, those being the Commanders, Rams, and Raiders.

The Commanders have long been the obvious destination for Aiyuk, given his friendship with Washington quarterback Jayden Daniels. The two played together at Arizona State and have frequently worked out together during off-seasons.

The two went through a rough patch this past off-season as they engaged in something of a social media feud.

“[Aiyuk] kind of said some things about Jayden Daniels’ mom. I can’t imagine that went over well in that locker room," Fowler said. “I don’t know where Washington stands on that, but I can say that Jayden Daniels and Brandon Aiyuk have reconciled. I’m told their relationship is now good, whereas with some of the stuff on Instagram, it wasn’t right.”

The Raiders have been mentioned as a potential destination for Aiyuk for a couple of reasons. First, Las Vegas head coach Klint Kubiak was the passing game coordinator for the 49ers in 2023—the year that Aiyuk had his most productive NFL season. Also, Fernando Mendoza’s top target, Brock Bowers, is currently hobbled with an ankle injury.

The Rams are another team that could take a look at Aiyuk, given the recent injury to star receiver Puka Nacua.

All told, though, teams won’t exactly be falling over themselves to pick up Aiyuk when he is finally released by the Niners.

“I don’t know that there’s a natural home [for Aiyuk],” Fowler said. “People are always going to bet on talent. If you’ve got a first round talent, you tend to get more chances than others. But I’m skeptical that he can get a job right away.

“Drew Rosenhaus [Aiyuk’s agent] has a lot of connections. He’s one of the top agents in the NFL. Perhaps he can help with that and grease the runway to get [Aiyuk] a job somewhere.”

Complex Bets is the premier destination for the intersection of sports, culture, and fandom, featuring original programming for the modern bettor and trader. Join our community of over 1 million fans by following @complexbets on Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, and X, and subscribe on YouTube for exclusive storytelling across sports and prediction markets.

Related Stories

De'Zhaun Stribling Fantasy Football Injury Update When Will Be Back Return How Long Out
Bets

De’Zhaun Stribling Fantasy Football Injury Update: When Will WR Return?

The 49ers rookie was injured in Week 1. How much longer will he be out for?

Matt Burke32 days ago
Jonathon Brooks Fantasy Football Injury Update When Will Be Back Return
Bets

Jonathon Brooks Fantasy Football Injury Update: When Will Panthers RB Return?

The injury-plagued Carolina running back is on the shelf yet again. How long will Brooks be out for?

Matt Burke45 days ago
Christian McCaffrey Fantasy Football Injury Update
Bets

Christian McCaffrey Fantasy Football Injury Update: Is CMC Healthy Ahead of Week 1?

The RB was absent from 49ers practice throughout much of August. Will he be ready to play Week 1?

Matt Burke74 days ago